The Mystery Hole Podcast

unhinged discussions of a new mystery each episode. you’ll be dumber for listening.

Episodes

Apr 28, 2025

1hr 18 min

In this episode of The Mystery Hole Podcast, the crew examines the extremely British folklore concept of "Pig-Faced Women". Then, they tread on dangerous ground by investigating the completely real and definitely not made up secret society to end all secret societies, the Illuminati. 

Apr 14, 2025

1hr 13 min

On this episode of the Mystery Hole Podcast, the crew delves into a mysterious 500 year old Count of 18th century Europe (hmmmm....) and the Wild Men of the Appalachians. Also - a brief sojourn into Napoleon's based views on hygiene and romance. Not to be missed! 

Mar 31, 2025

54 min

In this special bottle episode, the Hole Crew finds their beloved Hole to be undergoing maintenance. To fill the time, the crew goes through several strange wiki articles. Nathan adds perhaps the most powerful cursed artifact to his collection, Viv comes up with a wild grift, and Lane's inability to recognize a motif makes this the grossest episode yet! 

Mar 17, 2025

1hr 23 min

On this week's episode of the Mystery Hole Podcast, the Spelunkers enjoy the low-hanging fruit and sweet waters of the old well they continually return to: Wikipedia's List of Unusual Deaths. Then, they examine the archetype of the Shadowy Advisor by reading about the lives of court magician John Dee and Rasputin, the Mad Monk. 

Mar 3, 2025

1hr 22 min

On this episode, the Hole Crew chats about Lane's hot dog collection, check in on the latest UAP news, ponder if Punxsutawney Phil is a cryptid, and go diving for sunken treasure. It's a thicc boi today, so strap in! 

Feb 17, 2025

1hr 19 min

Drawing inspiration from Black History Month, the Spelunkers delve into Afrocentric bits of interesting history and folklore. First on the docket - the enigmatic Yasuke, who was the first and only black samurai of feudal Japan. Then, the crew heads over to the Cryptid Corner to investigate Africa's most famous cryptid, the Mkele-mbembe. And finally, they look into some folklore of the Congo, including Africa's version of the vampire and - you guessed it - Africa's very own Weird Little Guy. 

Feb 3, 2025

1hr 22 min

The gang kicks off this week's episode by pondering fake tech nerd masculinity. Then, they check out aliens in The News. And finally, they infiltrate the Third Reich to get to the bottom of Nazis and the occult. Spoiler alert - it's real bad and dumb. 

Jan 20, 2025

1hr 7 min

An episode about - you guessed it - weird dudes who are found dead on the ground. Quite a specific theme but it works. 

Jan 7, 2025

1hr 12 min

Back at last, the Hole Folks look at the curious life of infamous miser and Ebenezer Scrooge prototype John Elwes. Then, they head into the Ural Mountains to discover the truth behind the Dyatlov's Pass Incident. Grab your coat it's going to be a chilly one! 

Dec 9, 2024

1hr 14 min

On this episode, the Spelunkers sojourn back down to Hell to take a gander at Paimon, the Demon of the Week. Then, shifting gears entirely, the crew continues their exploration into the mystery and majesty of the human form with the biographies of two extraordinarily large men - Angus MacCaskill and Daniel Lambert. 

What is this mess?

The Mystery Hole Podcast is a biweekly comedy podcast where three Appalachian burnouts ponder the unknown. Each week, we peer into the hole and discuss what we uncover. 



Topics include cryptids, ghosts, aliens, famous eaters, famous farters, weird guys of history, and which Looney Tunes characters we could take in a fight. 



Come get weird with us! 

Copyright 2023 All rights reserved.

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Version: 20241125